Pros and Cons of Wood Shake Shingles: Comparing Different Types

Pros and Cons of Wood Shake Shingles: Comparing Different Types
Image: Pros and Cons of Wood Shake Shingles: Comparing Different Types

When it comes to roofing, there are many options available. One of the most popular choices is wood shake shingles. Wood shake shingles have been used for centuries and can be seen in a variety of homes across the world. They offer great insulation and can last for years if properly maintained. But before deciding on wood shakes, it’s important to understand their pros and cons so you can make an informed decision about your roofing material.

Wood shake shingles are made from split cedar logs or other hardwoods that have been cut into thin strips, with each strip having a smooth face and textured back side. This type of siding has unique characteristics such as its warm colors, rustic appearance, natural weather-resistant properties, fire resistance, durability and low maintenance requirements which makes them ideal for residential applications. There are different types of wood shakes such as western red cedar or northern white pine but they all share the same general look: rough-hewn boards with irregular grain patterns running lengthwise along the board’s edge.

Wood shake shingle roofs come in two styles: hand-split (or random) shakes which have uneven edges; or machine-cut (or straight) shakes which are uniform in size but still contain some texture along their faces to give them an aged look over time. Both styles require special installation techniques including nailing at least 4 nails per piece into sheathing beneath the siding while leaving 1/4″ between each nail head and allowing enough room for expansion due to temperature changes throughout the year – this helps keep your home comfortable during summer months when temperatures soar.

The main advantage of using wood shake shingles is that they add character and charm to any home exterior design – plus they’re durable enough to stand up against strong winds without compromising aesthetics. The biggest downside? Cost – these products typically cost more than asphalt or composite materials because of their labor intensive production process combined with premium lumber prices associated with certain types like Western Red Cedar varieties which often drive up overall costs significantly compared to other materials available today. Wood shakes may not be suitable for climates prone to extreme heat or cold temperatures since expansion gaps need extra attention during installation – however this should not deter homeowners who live in moderate climates since those gaps will help protect against moisture damage over time!

I. Overview of Wood Shake Shingles

I. Overview of Wood Shake Shingles
Image: I. Overview of Wood Shake Shingles

Wood shake shingles are an attractive roofing option that has become increasingly popular in recent years. These hand-cut wooden roofing materials come in a variety of sizes and shapes, giving homeowners the ability to customize their roofs with unique textures and patterns. While they offer plenty of aesthetic advantages, there are some important considerations to keep in mind before installing wood shakes on your home’s roof.

One major consideration is cost: wood shake shingles can be significantly more expensive than asphalt or other composite alternatives due to the labor required for installation. Wood shakes may require additional maintenance over time compared to other types of roofing materials; as a natural product, it is vulnerable to weather elements such as wind, rain and snow which can cause them to rot or warp if not properly treated with sealant and stain after installation.

When selecting wood shake shingle material for your home’s roof, it’s important to understand how different types will affect the overall look of your house. Cedar shakes tend to be more traditional looking while redwood provides a more rustic feel; both have distinct grain patterns that can create very different aesthetics depending on the type you choose. It’s also important to consider what color stain you want applied since this will play into the overall appearance once installed – lighter stains tend work best on larger roofs while darker colors blend better with smaller houses and cottages.

II. Benefits of Wood Shakes

II. Benefits of Wood Shakes
Image: II. Benefits of Wood Shakes

Wood shakes provide a unique look to your roof that can give any home a classic, rustic feel. It’s natural texture and durability are both qualities that make it an attractive option for many homeowners. Its ability to age well and withstand different climates also makes wood shakes ideal for those looking for a long-term investment in their roofing material.

When installed correctly, wood shake shingles offer superior protection against the elements due to their thickness and density. This makes them especially effective at keeping out rain, snow, wind and other debris from entering the home or building structure which can cause damage over time if left unchecked. Because of its naturally fire-resistant properties, wood shake shingles may be able to reduce homeowner insurance premiums as well as increase overall safety levels around the property in question by providing an additional layer of protection from potential fires or lightning strikes.

One of the greatest advantages of choosing wooden shakes is that they require very little maintenance compared to other types of materials used on roofs such as asphalt shingles or metal sheets; making them easier on the pocketbook when it comes time for repairs or replacement down the line. Furthermore they’re relatively lightweight so they won’t put extra strain on existing support structures while still being durable enough to stand up against tough weather conditions like heavy winds or hail storms without buckling under pressure like some lighter materials might do after prolonged exposure.

III. Drawbacks to Wooden Shingles

III. Drawbacks to Wooden Shingles
Image: III. Drawbacks to Wooden Shingles

One major drawback to wooden shingles is their tendency to break down over time. This breakdown can be caused by weather, insects, and other factors that can cause the wood to rot or become brittle. Many homeowners find that they need to replace their wooden shingles more often than other types of roofing materials such as asphalt shingle or metal roofs.

Another disadvantage of using wood shake shingles is their susceptibility to fire damage. Although some woods are naturally resistant to fire, most woods used in construction are not particularly flame-retardant and may require special treatments in order for them to meet local building codes regarding fire safety. If a home has an existing wooden structure such as framing members or siding boards which could easily catch on fire if exposed directly to flames from a nearby wildfire event then the use of wooden shingles could put the entire structure at risk for destruction by those fires.

Because wood shakes come in various shapes and sizes it can be difficult for homeowners who are trying do-it-yourself projects with these types of roof tiles – especially when it comes time for cutting them into size and fitting them together properly on a sloped surface. Even experienced professionals may have difficulty getting all pieces laid out evenly so that water runs off properly without any gaps between tiles creating potential problems with leaks down the line due to improper installation techniques being used during setup process.

IV. Cost Considerations

IV. Cost Considerations
Image: IV. Cost Considerations

When it comes to roofing materials, cost is always a major consideration. When comparing wood shake shingles, there are several factors that will determine the overall cost of the project. The type of wood used for shakes can have an impact on price. Cedar shakes tend to be more expensive than other types of woods due to their durability and beauty. Cedar requires less maintenance over time and has a longer lifespan than other varieties of wood shingles, so they may actually save money in the long run by lasting longer without needing replacement or repair as often.

Another factor that affects cost is the size of your home or building and how much material you need to cover your entire roof with shakes. If you choose thicker shingle sizes like extra-thick or royal cuts, this can increase costs significantly because more material will be needed for installation than if using thinner sizes such as 3/8” thick standard cuts which require less material for coverage but also provide less protection from elements such as wind damage.

Labor costs should also be taken into account when considering the overall cost of installing wood shake shingles on your roof since experienced professionals must handle these jobs properly and safely in order to ensure optimal results that last long term without any issues arising later down the road due to improper installation techniques being used during initial setup stages – something inexperienced DIYers should avoid attempting unless they are confident in their abilities or willing to accept potential costly mistakes along with increased risks associated with taking on such projects themselves rather than hiring professional help who know what they’re doing when it comes time for installation duties at hand.

V. Installation Process

V. Installation Process
Image: V. Installation Process

Installing wood shake shingles is a fairly straightforward process, though some particularities of the material can add complexity to the job. The general process involves first preparing the roof and then affixing each individual shingle one at a time.

When it comes to prepping for installation, it’s important to make sure that any prior layer of roof covering has been completely removed. This is especially true if dealing with asphalt shingles or other materials which may contain chemicals that could damage wood shakes over time. All nails and screws must be properly secured so as not to cause further wear and tear on new shingles when they are installed.

Once these steps have been taken, installation can begin in earnest by applying an underlayment beneath the wooden shakes followed by securing them into place with galvanized nails or staples in accordance with local building codes. It’s also worth noting that overlapping shingles should generally be avoided since this can lead to premature deterioration due to trapped moisture beneath them. Extra care should always be taken around flashing areas such as chimneys and vents where leaks are more likely without proper sealing techniques employed during installation.

VI. Maintenance Requirements

VI. Maintenance Requirements
Image: VI. Maintenance Requirements

When it comes to wood shake shingles, maintenance is an important factor that should not be overlooked. In order for these roofing materials to last and remain in good condition, they need regular upkeep such as cleaning, repair work, and replacement of any damaged or worn out shingles. The type of maintenance required will vary depending on the type of wood shake shingle chosen.

Cedar shakes require a more intensive level of care due to their natural properties which make them susceptible to rot over time. This means that they need extra protection from the elements by being properly treated with sealants or preservatives every few years in order to extend their lifespan and keep them looking great. Cedar shakes may also require more frequent repairs compared to other types since they are prone to splitting and warping due to extreme temperatures or weather conditions.

On the other hand, pressure-treated pine shakes offer a longer life span but have less aesthetic appeal than cedar varieties since they tend to fade faster when exposed directly to sunlight or rainwater for long periods of time. Although this material does not need as much protection from moisture like cedar does, regular cleaning is still recommended in order for it retain its attractive appearance over time. Pressure-treated pine shakes also require periodic inspection for signs of decay so that any necessary repairs can be addressed quickly before further damage occurs.

VII. Cedar vs. Redwood Shake Shingles

VII. Cedar vs. Redwood Shake Shingles
Image: VII. Cedar vs. Redwood Shake Shingles

Cedar and redwood are two popular types of wood shake shingles that many homeowners consider when deciding what type of roof to install. Cedar shakes have a classic look, with a slightly rustic feel, while redwood is known for its durability and unique grain pattern. Both materials can provide your home with great protection from the elements, but there are some differences between them that you should be aware of before making your final decision.

When it comes to longevity, cedar shakes tend to last around 20-30 years depending on their location and maintenance level. Redwood shakes generally have a longer lifespan than cedar – up to 40 or 50 years in some cases – due to their more durable composition. However, both materials require periodic cleaning and staining treatments in order to maintain their strength against UV rays and other environmental factors.

Cost-wise, cedar tends to be cheaper than redwood as it’s easier to find and work with than its counterpart; however this doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s the better option as redwood can offer superior protection from moisture damage over time if properly maintained. Both woods come in various grades which will affect the cost even further so make sure you do your research beforehand.

VIII. Synthetic Alternatives

VIII. Synthetic Alternatives
Image: VIII. Synthetic Alternatives

Synthetic alternatives to wood shake shingles have become increasingly popular in recent years. While traditional wooden shingles may be aesthetically pleasing, synthetic materials offer a more cost-effective and long-term solution for roof protection. Synthetics can come in many forms such as plastic, rubber or even composite materials that are made from recycled materials. These types of shingles provide the same level of durability and waterproofing as their wooden counterparts while also being less expensive to install and maintain.

In terms of longevity, synthetic alternatives typically last much longer than wood shakes with some having warranties up to 50 years. This makes them an excellent choice if you’re looking for a roof that won’t need replacing any time soon. They are resistant to fire and wind damage which is something most homeowners should consider when selecting a material for their roof. They require very little maintenance compared to other types of shingle materials so you won’t have to worry about costly repairs or replacements down the line.

The main drawback with synthetic options is that they often don’t look quite as good as natural wood shakes due to their lack of texture or color variation across each individual piece. However this doesn’t mean that your home has to look dull; there are plenty of different styles available on the market today so you can find something that suits your taste perfectly.

Scroll to Top